Find a copy in the library
Finding libraries that hold this item...
Details
| Genre/Form: | Popular Works |
|---|---|
| Additional Physical Format: | Online version: Pinker, Steven, 1954- Language instinct. New York : W. Morrow and Co., c1994 (OCoLC)646971227 |
| Document Type: | Book |
| All Authors / Contributors: |
Steven Pinker |
| ISBN: | 0688121411 9780688121419 |
| OCLC Number: | 28723210 |
| Description: | 494 p. : ill. ; 25 cm. |
| Responsibility: | Steven Pinker. |
Abstract:
Reviews
WorldCat User Reviews (1)
Major work in linguistics and evolutionary psychology
Pinker's Language Instinct is in its own league, not only in the perspective that it imparts, but in the quality of the writing. Pinker brings Chomsky's universal grammar to the masses, explaining how the mind processes linguistic structures. He then shows how the brain has to perform several distinct...
Read more...
Pinker's Language Instinct is in its own league, not only in the perspective that it imparts, but in the quality of the writing. Pinker brings Chomsky's universal grammar to the masses, explaining how the mind processes linguistic structures. He then shows how the brain has to perform several distinct and complex operations in real time in order to use and understand language.
He then takes this complexity and shows what Chomsky had long concluded: that it has to come pre-constructed. It is an instinct, hardwired into human nature, and not some cultural fad. He then argues, contra Chomsky, that this hardwired complexity could only have come about via evolution by natural selection. Chomsky thinks of language in the abstract, as a snowflake, symmetrical and perfect. Pinker shows that how the brain implements that algorithm is full of kludges and compromises. The brain's language instinct is a tinkerer's construction, like a giraffe's neck, the product of natural selection.
The case that he makes for modular components of the mind coordinating to create an instinct is all the more powerful because it is supported by many lines of evidence. Other evolutionary psychologists have a more difficult time making the case for a module for this behavior, a module for that behavior, because the functions are not so clear cut. But with language, grammar is razor sharp, and becomes the exemplar for the existence of evolved brain modules.
So while other theories of evolutionary psychology can be attacked because of a narrow range of evidence, for example John Dupre criticizing David Buss's theories of sexual behavior, Pinker presses his points in his later books such as "How the Mind Works" from the unassailable position of the language instinct.
Not only that, but there are a lot of jokes in this book, which make it a fun read, Chomsky's grammar notwithstanding.
- Was this review helpful to you?
Tags
All user tags (1)
- evolutionary psychology (by 1 person)
- 1 items are tagged withevolutionary psychology
Similar Items
Related Subjects:(10)
- Language and languages.
- Biolinguistics.
- Language -- Popular Works.
- Language Development -- Popular Works.
- Verbal Behavior -- Popular Works.
- Langage et langues.
- Biolinguistique.
- Taalpsychologie.
- Sprache.
- Kognition.
User lists with this item (16)
- Books reviewed(129 items)
by vleighton updated about a month ago
- Books to Read - Non-Fiction(58 items)
by hp6smiles updated 2012-03-09
- PHIL 173 - Harrington(28 items)
by jcurrie updated 2012-02-08
- References(16 items)
by blunny updated 2012-01-14
- speech-language pathology(458 items)
by sbloom updated 2011-12-01


